Yesterday, we noted that Judge Nathan had dismissed a state law unfair competition claim brought against Aereo, an online television service, on the grounds that it was preempted by the Copyright Act. Today, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Public Knowledge moved for permission to file an amicus brief on behalf of Aereo to counter the surviving claims against Aereo under the Copyright Act itself. In the amicus brief attached to the motion, the EFF and PK argue that Aereo’s business is protected by Cartoon Network LP v. CSC Holdings, Inc., 536 F.3d 121 (2d Cir. 2008), which held that “the transmission of a copyrighted work is a private performance outside the exclusive rights of the copyright owner when it is one-to-one, that is, made to a single individual or family and social acquaintances.” Here, the amici argue that the transmittal of broadcast television over the internet is no different from recording live TV on a VCR or DVR and watching it (among friends or alone) at a later time.
Recent Blog Posts
Judge Pauley Bemoans Needlessly Long and Complicated Pleadings Judge Swain, Based on “Implicit” Overruling of Second Circuit, Rules 3-Year Limit to Sue Over False Securities Offerings Is Not Subject to “Extender” Law Judge Rakoff Denies Class Cert Where Class Rep Faced Unique Defense Relating to “Netting” of Losses Judge Torres Grants Police Unions a Say in Stop-and-Frisk Reform Efforts Judge Hellerstein Rules That Spanish Bank With New York Branch Must Gather Information Globally for Judgment Collection Subpoena FHFA Trial Against Nomura, RBS Begins Monday Before Judge Cote Judge Francis Recommends Denying Class Certification in Goldman Gender Bias Case Judge Crotty Dismisses Trademark Case Against Oprah Over Phrase “Own Your Power” Judge Peck Publishes, For Guidance to Practitioners, Parties’ Protocol for Technology-Assisted Document Review Newly Unsealed Complaint Accuses U.S. Attorney of Fabricating Evidence for Raid that Led to Hedge Fund’s Collapse